Design for reliability techniques worst case circuit. An approach of the worst case analysis of the analog electronic circuits based on the circuit description in parameter space is proposed. From the design analysis handbook by ed walker worst case analysis wca is the mathematical determination of the limits of possible performance of a system to ensure that the desired system responses will not exceed specification limits and that. The results of this analysis and any associated circuit modifications are an important element in the initial development process. For example, the gain error introduced by nonideal resistors. Worst case analysis, electronic parts circuit tolerance analysis, worst case scenario, worst case part. To capture worst case induced voltage, the analysis is run twice. Worstcase design techniques do not change the basic transfer equations for an op amp circuit. How to model diodes for highfrequency susceptibility analysis. An approach to worstcase circuit analysis semantic scholar. When designing a circuit in ltspice, you may wish to assess the impact of component tolerances. Worst case circuit analysis wcca worst case circuit analysis wcca is a technique which, by accounting for component variability, determines circuit performance under a worst case scenario, i. When a worstcase analysis is performed on a circuit, the following procedure is followed.
For example, if one of the components is a 10k ohm resistor with a 5% tolerance, worstcase analysis will only use resistance values of 10. Ltspice tutorial ep worst case, monte carlo and gaussian. For our example, we had drawn a group of resistors powered by 12vdc supply. A worstcase analysis is a quantitative assessment of a circuit or. Worst case analysis equation 2 is rewritten as equation 6 see below, which includes the total tolerance and has been written to obtain the maximum value of the transfer equation. Such an analysis is based on the sensitivity analysis 4. Worstcase tolerance analysis is the starting point when creating a tolerance specification it is a conservative approach as it only considers the maximum or minimum values of part variationwhichever leads to the worst situation. I need to determine the worstcase output voltage range for the circuit shown in figure 2 when the photodiode exposed to a light level of 6. So, for the above example any given resistor could be a maximum of 32% from the nominal value. In this video i demonstrate using ltspices built in monte carlo function and also a userdefined worst case function in a simple design. The dc photodiode current enters on the leftside of the circuit. Introduction to worst case circuit analysis course overview. Monte carlo analysis is, therefore, essential to worstcase circuit analysis wcca.
Extreme value analysis eva eva involves evaluating a circuits performance using every possible combination of extreme component value. Therefore, a wccsa must encompass all of these worst cases. Worst case analysis often is used for design and analysis of mos and bjt ic circuits. Worstcase error analysis and calibration in temperature. Part parameter variation is the result of both internal and external factors. Ltspice monte carlo and worst case simulations youtube. See ec0240 for directions when using a monte carlo analyusis.
For wcca the designer ensures that under all use cases and all conceivable and. Introduction to worst case circuit analysis for the. The proper documentation formats for communicating the analysis results is explained with detailed examples allowing the participant to gain a full understanding. Worstcase circuit analysis wcca is a costeffective means of screening a design to verify with a high degree of confidence that potential defects and deficiencies are identified and eliminated. Find nominal values and then select r1, r2, and vs values to. Why worstcase circuit analysis is challenging to perform edn. Less widely found is bestcase performance, but it does have uses. A comparison of tolerance analysis methods by steven m. Worstcase circuit analysis with minimal simulations runs. Monte carlo analysis in excel a design tool for the. Worst case circuit anaysis and schematic design are often done at the same time. Average performance and worstcase performance are the most used in algorithm analysis. There are many, many axes of worst or merely goodbad and contexts to go with it.
A worstcase analysis is a quantitative assessment of a circuit or systems functional performance, accounting for manufacturing, environmental, aging, and, in the case of space applications, radiation tolerances. Worstcase circuit analysis wcca or wca is a costeffective means of screening a design to ensure with a high degree of confidence that potential defects and deficiencies are identified and eliminated prior to and during test, production, and delivery it is a quantitative assessment of the equipment performance, accounting for manufacturing, environmental and aging effects. However, for a worst case analysis we would prefer not to use a distribution approach, instead the maximum deviation from the nominal value of each component are used in the calculations. Worst case analysis is used to identify the most critical components which will affect circuit performance. Worst case circuit stress analysis advanced energy. Statistical worst case design analysis allows each component to be at its minimum or maximum value and then, based on the interaction of the individual components, computes the minimum and maximum expected performance values. Worst case circuit analysis an overview e e c t r n i p s. Once with the diode in saturation and once with the diode off. Worst case circuit analysis is a method for determining circuit performance under extreme worst case conditions. It is a conservative approach as it only considers the maximum or minimum values of part variation, whichever leads to the worst situation. Gribble, 36 a preregulation case, would not have required worst case analysis since the agency had sufficient data about the catastrophe to make a reasoned decision on whether to build the dam.
Worstcase design of op amp circuits introduction building reliable hardware requires all component tolerances to be accounted for during the design stage. Since it is unlikely that several independent variables will attain their worst case values simultaneously, this technique tends to be overly pessimistic, and. Worst case analysis of the analog circuits proceedings. Today, the availability of highspeed digital computers and circuit analysis pro grams has eased the task of performing an accurate worstcase analysis of circuits. Circuit under analysis process and application data prior product information. This process is accomplished by analyzing a circuits variability with respect to part parameter tolerance extremes. Worst case analysis an overview sciencedirect topics. In this example we looked at the impact of resistor tolerances in a classical difference amplifier, and the value of the matched resistors in the lt19973 are illustrated. Find the nominal and worstcase values for output voltage and source current. C monte carlo defined by the probability distnbution of the variability no sensitivity analysis required. Initially a sensitivity analysis is run on each individual component which has a tolerance assigned. Complete the following steps to configure and run a worst case analysis.
Reliability and worst case analysis accendo reliability. Participants learn the importance of this analysis and the different methods which can be utilized. We have seen many methods of calculating the worst case tolerance limits for electronic circuits. In this video i will be explaining how to use ltspice to perform a worst case analysis for tolerance. Worstcase analysis of electronic circuits based on an. Configuring a worst case analysis in multisim national. The results can be evaluated statistically using expected means, standard deviations, and yields. The worst case is simulated by taking all variables to their 2sigma or 3sigma worst case values. Why you really need a wca worst case analysis developpa. I look at are worst case analysis, monte carlo and gaussian statistical circuit. The approach that is typically followed is to define worst case component variations based on.
The purpose of this paper is to evaluate the worstcase behavior of a given electronic circuit by varying the values of the components in a meaningful way in order not to exceed predefined currents or voltages limits during a transient operation. For example, you have to measure the voltage of a battery present in your circuit. In its simplest concept, a worst case analysis is the quantification of a signal given the absolute maximum and minimum that the signal can change in the context of that circuit and its given environment in order to compare it with the circuit specifications and requirements. The proper documentation format for communicating the analysis results is explained with detailed examples allowing the participant to gain a full understanding. Worst case analysis, electronic partscircuit tolerance analysis,worst case scenario, worst case part. Using the method outlined above, a simple worstcase analysis can be run at the minmax value of several parameters. Worst case circuit analysis with minimal simulations runs. Edn why worstcase circuit analysis is challenging to. Design and analysis of electronic circuits for worst case environments and part variations c rootsumsquare defined by the biases and standard deviations of the parts variability and magnitude of circuit sensitivities. This example applies to all electronic parts in the circuit being analysed. This intensive course focuses on the fundamental skills required to perform a worst case circuit analysis wcca. Dennis fitzpatrick, in analog design and simulation using orcad capture and pspice second edition, 2018. Tolerances can be assigned to the circuit elements for use in montecarlo or worstcase analyses. The worst case method simply adds the dimensions using the extreme values for those dimensions.
In this example you will use worst case analysis to determine if the circuit will continue to oscillate under the worst conditions. The intent of this paper is to demonstrate several different methods, and determine the results, and the corresponding confidence factors for each method. Introduction to worst case circuit analysis for the automotive engineer course overview. Worstcase circuit analysis, analog electronic circuit, polytope. References 1 and 2 introduce the concepts of absolute and ratiometric measurement methods, while references 3 and 4 present theoretical analysis showing the impact of undesired circuit component variations on accurate sensor readings. Pdf wcca worst case circuit analysis pedro vitoriano. Worst case analysis wca of electronic circuits has been a standard way of showing that a circuit meets the minimum design requirements as defined by the customer. Worst case circuit analysis an overview e 1 e c t r o n i c p art s c i r cu i t s to 1 er an ce an a 1 y s i s walter m. Worst case tolerance analysis is the starting point when creating a tolerance specification.
The worst case analysis results refer to the worst case values at the circuit outputs and performance specifications produced when a circuit component or device model change its parameter value. Each wcca is a quantitative assessment of hardware performance that accounts for manufacturing. Note that it shows the statistical approach falls within the worstcase condition. The worst case is often not at the parametric extremes and you will miss findings if you do eva only. A simulation is performed with all variables in the circuit set to their nominal values. Wcca is the best method to ensure a rugged product design.
Improve logic timing with worstcase analysis electronic. For example, the ninth circuit explained in socats 35 that the potential catastrophic collapse of a proposed dam in warm springs dam task force, inc. The sample design used as a teaching aid is a single. A dc, ac or transient worstcase analysis can be performed only testing the circuit for the vertices of a polytope in conjunction with a. Step by step guide for worst case analysis sensitivity analysis in pspice.
Pdf an approach to worstcase circuit analysis elena. Worstcase circuit analysis wcca or wca is a costeffective means of screening a design to ensure with a high degree of confidence that potential defects and. Participants learn the importance of this analysis as it relates to assessing functional hazards, circuit margin and risk assessment, and. The two graphs below show the results for the resistor on the left. Figure 1 worst case circuit stress analysis process flow, adapted from 2, 3. We will be looking at resistors for this example but this can be applied to all parts that. The circuit and its function are really very simple. Performing extreme value analysis eva assessments alone is insufficient and results in many analyses that dont produce the worst possible results. Teaming a formalized worstcase design procedure with computer circuit analysis pro grams such as ecap ref. Worstcase analysis worstcase circuit analysis is an analysis technique which, by accounting for component variability, determines the circuit performance under a worstcase scenario.
1132 1168 1028 390 1404 960 391 767 423 665 785 1492 56 374 836 230 1306 51 86 15 967 63 1322 58 459 332 626 131 911 1524 1376 223 336 1446 1166 924 170 759 1223 308 748 525 61